Breakfast in bed, messy pets, toddlers still undergoing potty training, and hot-blooded nighttime adventures with your partner(s?) are some of the few reasons why your bed may be at risk of liquid damage. Thankfully, with the right mattress protector, you can shield your mattress from all the messes and potential damages that may result from these daring escapades.
Quality protective covers can also significantly extend your mattress’s lifespan by reducing the wear and tear from daily usage while keeping out all allergens, dust mites, and bed bugs.
However, like with most shopping decisions for your bedroom, choosing the perfect mattress protector for your bed is no easy feat.
The ideal candidate for the total protection of your bed must be waterproof (not just on the label but also in practice) and tough enough to handle the physical impact from daily use and all types of pollutants.
With this report, we are taking out all the guesswork from choosing the perfect mattress protector. We have crunched the numbers and reviewed all of the top contenders to bring you the best protective covers you can buy for your bed today.
Our Top Pick: Casper Mattress Protector
Like their popular flagship bed, the Casper Mattress, this mattress protector from Casper represents arguably the best offering in the category. With the Casper Mattress Protector, what you get is less of a standard mattress cover by more of a mattress protector/pad hybrid.
This unique cover packs a plush, luxurious feel that adds even more comfort to your sleeping setup yet provides enough protection to rival even the sturdiest standard protectors.
However, the Casper mattress protector takes things a step further, packing two extra quilted knit layers, with one on either side of the waterproof layer.
These comfort layers add a considerable amount of plushness that makes this mattress cover one of the best options on the market in terms of comfort (an area where many protectors with their bare and squeaky polyethylene often fail.)
The structure also includes an integrated spacer layer that prevents it from overheating by maximizing airflow through the layers.
The soft feel you get with this unique mattress protector is enough to justify making the purchase. However, an added benefit that the comfort layers bring that is hard to ignore is minimizing noise levels.
The Casper mattress protector also packs a tight-fitting skirting material that snugly hugs the side of your mattress and prevents any shifting during the night.
Thanks to this skirting section and Casper’s standard sizing scheme, you can rest assured that this protective cover will snugly fit all standard-sized mattresses up to 16 inches in thickness.
Casper recommends washing the protector once to unshrink it if it doesn’t fit at first. This tip also works for most standard waterproof mattress protectors.
With its mix of waterproof protection, comfort, and breathability, the Casper mattress protector offers one of the best options you can get on the market today. However, with its considerable price range of $85-$105, it also represents one of the most expensive of the lot.
Nevertheless, the Casper mattress protector presents one of the best value propositions on the market and is a hard deal to turn down.
- Polyethylene waterproof layer provides all the spill protection you will ever need
- Quilted polyester and spandex blend top provides a luxurious feel and added comfort while keeping noise levels low
- With polyester, nylon, and spandex blend skirt, complete with a 360° grip for a snug movement-free fit
- Suitable for standard mattresses with a depth of up to 16 inches
- Machine-washable. Tumble dry on low
- With free shipping and returns
- 1-year limited warranty
- More pricey than most
Other 6 Excellent Waterproof Mattress Protectors: Detailed Reviews
The Casper mattress protector arguably represents the pinnacle in waterproof covers for your mattress. However, not everyone is willing to shell out around 100 bucks for a mattress protector.
Other buyers may find it hard to justify such a purchase, considering that they already have considerably comfortable sleeping setups and do not need the extra perks the Casper mattress cover offers.
Nevertheless, some buyers are more than willing to buy mattress protectors at that price point and will welcome even more expensive offerings that pack an even more robust feature-set.
Whichever category you fall into, fret not as we have other picks to satisfy your needs.
The mattress protector market segment is heavy with reliable options, and you will have no problem finding the right cover for you at any price point. Here are some other top contenders that you can snag today.
1. SafeRest Waterproof Mattress Protector
No discussion of the top mattress protector can be complete without mentioning this bestseller from SafeRest.
The SafeRest Premium Waterproof Mattress Protector is Amazon’s best-selling mattress protector with over 25,000 5-star reviews and countless other customer reviews raving about its efficacy.
- Relatively neutral feel of the protector helps retains your mattress’s original feel
- Suitable for beds with depths up to 18 inches
- With breathable cotton terry topping
- Competitive pricing
- Fitted sheet-style design
- 10-year warranty
SafeRest winning formula is a simple construction that works wonders for maximizing both mattress protection and comfort for the sleeper, yet retails at a low dirt price that is hard to refuse.
SafeRest mattress protectors use an ingenious dual-sided layer that is so good; it should arguably be up there in contention for the industry standard.
Up top, you get a cotton terry surface that is soft, plush against the skin and keeps the cover comfy, super breathable, and completely noise-free.
On the other hand, the protector’s underside features a waterproof membrane back coating that brings all of the fluid protection, completing arguably one of the best construction styles in the category.
Thanks to the cotton terry surface’s neutralizing effect, you get zero noise when sleeping on this masterpiece. Plus, the relatively neutral feel of the slim protector means that you can use it with any mattress type (latex, memory foam, or innerspring) and still retain a relatively similar feel as you would get sleeping on the mattress without a protective cover.
Cotton is also hypoallergenic, so it provides extra protection against dust mites and allergens.
The clincher is that the SafeRest Premium Waterproof Mattress Protector currently retails for under 30 bucks, a price point that is sure to win over many potential buyers.
However, the SafeRest mattress protector is not your average budget option. Regardless of pricing, this offering ranks up there as one of the best in the category.
2. Layla Essential Mattress Protector
Layla, another behemoth in the space, have their own OEM mattress protector available for purchase. Here, the company provides a dependable replacement for the Casper mattress protector (without the perks) that retails for half the price.
- Suitable for beds with depths of up to 14 inches
- Waterproof and dust resistant
The Essential mattress protector is a barebones product that features a single-layer liquid barrier that keeps your bed dry without adding any extra comfort.
This protector features a lightweight polyester construction, complete with elastic corners for a perfect fit and easy removals. Plus, the lightweight polyester does an excellent job of keeping things quiet during use. However, its noise performance is still slightly subpar compared to the Casper; hence, you can expect the occasional plasticky crunchy sound during sleep.
Nevertheless, the Layla Essential is excellent at its job—keeping your mattress liquid-proof. The cover is fully resistant to liquids, dust, dander, and allergens. Hence, if you are looking for an essential mattress protector you can trust, Layla’s option will get the job done.
The one major con with the Essential mattress protector is that it is still quite pricey for a basic offering. Notwithstanding, with Layla, you can rest assured that you are getting some of the best construction quality on the market.
Plus, if you are willing to shell out a few extra bucks, Layla also offers two other deluxe options.
The company also ships the Layla Cooling Mattress Protector that adds extra padding and increases breathability and the Layla Full Encasement Mattress Protector that packs a sturdier build reinforced to offer more resistance to the elements and wear and tear.
3. Cuddledown Waterproof Flannel Mattress Protector
The winter months are upon us, and it’s that time of the year again when you need as much warmth as you can get.
- Soft and comfy flannel build
- Excellent temperature regulation
- OEKO-TEX® certified
- Made in the U.S.A
- Suitable for mattresses with depths of up to 17 inches
Many mattress protector options are notorious for running hot and making you overheat during sleep, so you should have no worries there going with any of the options available on the market. However, where the Cuddledown mattress protector stands above all others as a winter option is its coziness.
The Cuddledown Waterproof Mattress Protector features a 100% cotton flannel construction that is soft to the touch and excellent for comfortable sleep. Here, instead of creating noise and rustle, you get a smooth mattress protector that enhances the feel of your sleeping surface.
This cover also packs an inner breathable layer that enhances the airflow through the structure, ensuring that your body temperature stays adequately regulated through the night.
This mix of heat retention and airflow that the materials create helps the protector store and release heat periodically to keep your body at a stable (and comfortable) temperature throughout the night.
4. Keetsa Waterproof Mattress Protector
One of the biggest problems with many of the top mattress protectors on the market is breathability. With their waterproof mattress protector, Keetsa aims to fix this problem by providing a mattress cover that doubles as a protector.
- Comfy linen-blend top layer
- With polyurethane back coating for 100% moisture-resistance
- Stretch side fabric for a perfect mattress fit
- OEKO-TEX® certified
- Machine washable (cold wash)
Here, you can forget about all the crunchiness you get with standard polyester mattress protectors.
Keetsa waterproof mattress protector utilizes a unique hybrid design that combines your regular fitted sheet with a mattress protector, creating an all-around performer that keeps all moisture out yet packs enough comfiness to use standalone, with any extra toppings.
This protector features a linen, cotton, and polyester blend fabric that creates a super-absorbent, moisture-wicking sleep surface. This layer’s underside sports a protective polyurethane film coating that brings the moisture-resistance and protects your mattress from any spills.
The Keetsa Waterproof Mattress Protector works like any regular deep-pocketed fitted sheet, hugging your mattress snugly and providing an extra layer of comfort. The protective cover includes an elastic side fabric that ensures a perfect fit irrespective of mattress depth.
5. The Company Store Waterproof Mattress Pad
Most mattress protectors typically feature light materials and flimsy constructions, as their main goal is to keep your mattress dry. However, with its distinctive protective mattress pad, the Company Store takes a different route.
- Comfy mattress pad with 400-thread count cotton cover
- Suitable for mattresses with a depth of up to 22 inches
- Laminate waterproofing minimizes rustle
Here, you get a fully fleshed-out piece, designed to provide all-round protection for your mattress while significantly enhancing your comfort levels.
The Company Store Waterproof Mattress Pad is a full-on mattress pad that features a silky soft 400-thread count cotton cover with 10 ounces of polyester fill. Hence, this protector adds considerable cushioning to your bed and acts as an additional cozy layer that lovers of comfort will appreciate.
However, this comfy pad packs all the protection you need too. The protector sports a waterproof laminate topping that keeps out all liquids and protects your mattress from spills.
With The Company Store Waterproof Mattress Pad, you get the ultimate mix of comfort and mattress protection that few competitors can hold a candle to in terms of overall performance. Plus, with a queen-size retailing for 99 bucks, this piece offers an excellent price-to-value ratio.
6. AllerEase Waterproof Mattress Protector
While the main reason why many buyers purchase mattress protectors is to make their bed liquid-proof, there are a host of other types of pollutants that can damage your mattress and make it unsuitable for sleep. Some of the most notorious of these include allergens, bed bugs, and mites.
- Suitable for mattresses with depths of up to 12 inches
- Blocks out all allergens and insects
- 360° protection with zippered closure
- Machine-washable at warm setting
The unique waterproof mattress protector from AllerEase aims to be the end all be all when it comes to protecting you from irritants and tiny insects.
The AllerEase Waterproof Mattress Protector features a polyester blend fabric that is tough enough to withstand bed bug bites and prevents these insects from going through. This protector also offers 360° protection as it covers all six sides of the mattress and includes a zippered seal that blocks out allergens, dust, bugs, fleas, and mites.
Plus, you can machine wash this protector at a warm setting (manufacturer recommendation), which further helps sterilize the fabric and kill any residual insects or bacteria.
Furthermore, AllerEase takes customer satisfaction very seriously as they offer a 10-year limited warranty with each mattress protector.